Motley Crue was joined by former Idol winner, Carrie Underwood, for the finale and well, I don’t think things turned out the way Motley Crue would have liked.

Carrie Underwood has been working with a few rock stars over the last few years including Guns & Roses as well as adding several rock covers to her live shows. I get why they asked her to perform; former winner and huge rock band to close out the season. The problem is Underwood clearly outperformed Vince Neil, leaving some fans to call for her to permanently replace Neil in the band. (ouch)

The video is below for you to check out.